Smoked Tri-Tip — Bringing the West Coast Cut to Middle Tennessee

Some of the smoking sites I follow are always posting about cooking tri-tip, but it’s a cut I’d never actually seen in stores here in Tennessee. It’s popular on the West Coast, sometimes called the Santa Maria cut, and it’s similar to London broil, though a different cut entirely. Much to my surprise, I found Sam’s had started carrying them — I picked one up for $14 to give it a try.

Smoked Tri-Tip Quick Reference

  • Marinade: olive oil, garlic, rosemary, and thyme, about 3 hours
  • Smoke: about 2 hours with mesquite (next time I’d use hickory)
  • Pull temp: 130°F internal, then rest
  • Sear: propane grill at 600°F, about 4 minutes total
  • Final rest: 10 minutes before slicing

 

What Is Tri-Tip?

Tri-tip gets its name from its shape — a distinctive triangle.

Tri-Tip Marinade

I put together a simple marinade of olive oil, garlic, rosemary, and thyme, and let it sit for about 3 hours before it went on the smoker.

How Long to Smoke Tri-Tip (and When to Pull It)

It smoked for about 2 hours using mesquite — though if I did it again, I’d try hickory instead, since the mesquite came through a little too strong for my taste. I pulled it at 130°F internal and let it rest.

Tri-tip pulled from the smoker at 130 degrees internal

Searing Tri-Tip on the Grill

I finished it with a hard sear on both sides on the propane grill, heated to 600°F — about 4 minutes total.

Tri-tip searing on the grill

How It Turned Out

I let it rest another 10 minutes before slicing. It came out cooked perfectly, and the marinade gave it great flavor — I just wasn’t sold on the mesquite. A couple of readers later chimed in with the same thought, suggesting pecan, oak, or a fruitwood instead — worth trying next time.

Tri-tip sliced for serving

2 Comments

  1. Gary says:

    Mesquite can be very harsh and sometimes bitter. I use Pecan , Oak or a fruitwood instead. I have cooked over 20 of these Trips-Tips on my WSM. I often apply Montreal Steak Seasoning prior to setting the Tri-Tip on the smoker grill. After reaching 130F internal, I remove the middle section of my bullet smoker and lower my grill with the Tri-Tip directly over the coals. 2-3 minutes on each side and it’s done!

Comments are closed.